IN SILENCE AND SOLITUDE ON THE LAST DAY OF THE YEAR and with only a few more hours to bid adieu to 2021; it is time to take stock of incidents of my life and draw up a balance sheet.
Friday, 31 December 2021
Balance Sheet 2021
Thursday, 9 December 2021
The Tale of Two Commissionarates
NEAR THE VICTORIA EMBANKMENT ON THAMES RIVER, ONE WOULD find this humble building with basic signage identifying it as the New Scotland Yard. This is the new headquarter of the London Metropolitan Police. Built in the year 1930, the Met Police operated out of this building till 1960. It is only in 2013 that the decision to relocate from its earlier place was taken and redesigned to suit the new age requirements. The old one is now converted into a hotel and is owned by an Indian.
The word Scotland Yard takes us to our growing up ages
where had pictured a stern disciplined efficient police force ready to crack down
the crime networks of London of that period. This imagery of the fabled
franchise and their slogan - Working together for a safer London was largely
influenced by the TV serials of that time and the novels we read. It was a tad
disappointing. The humble reality crushed my perception of that institution.
No match to the impressive Greco-roman architecture-inspired
Police Commissionerate we have back here in Bhubaneswar. Both were commissioned
around the same time in 2012, our Commissionerate building can be compared with
their National Gallery overlooking the famous Trafalgar Square. While ours was
an awe-inspiring structure with a large setback overlooking the second most important
road of the city, theirs was so timid in comparison.
The new age resurgent Indian in me felt good that like in
many other areas like Cricket and IT, we have beaten the Brits hands down on
one more count.
Back in my room after a tiring day after hopping on and
off buses and walking around large art galleries, I was tempted to revisit that
conflicting emotion of disappointment and pride upon seeing New Scotland Yard. My
trip to Westminster had evoked a similar feeling. At their Parliament building,
one could see the main entrance from the road which was just a few meters away.
MPs take the famous London bus service or come in the underground tube. No
security cordon thrown around it and no menacing marshals ordering you to keep
off the road or not to loiter. By looking at the Westminster and the Big Ben
clock behind it you wonder if the historical decisions you have read in your
textbooks were taken by people working in these places. It leaves you wondering
if it’s progressing into a weak state.
The sense of superiority that I was overcome with was now
overtaken by deep thought.
Everything about their Government and various arms of it
was so basic and accessible - so approachable. The country which was our colonizer
only 70 odd years back terrorizing generations of our ancestors its police and
policymakers maintain such low profile is a choice or its compulsion. I dug
further into various websites to know more about this building. One website
which talked about the underpinnings the building is built upon and what are values
it communicated to the people it serves read as follows.
“A revolving sign – one of the most iconic
features of the Met's old home in Victoria – has been retained and now
signposts the AHMM-designed entrance pavilion. Spanning almost the full width
of the front facade, the pavilion is raised on a pale stone plinth that
visually marries the addition with the Portland stone walls of the
original building. Its curving glass walls are intended to convey a message of
organizational transparency and create a ‘non-institutional’ entrance. The
pavilion is also intended as a memorial for officers who died in the line of
duty, with an eternal flame and contemplation pool visible through the
glazing.”
Two phrases ‘Organizational Transparency’ and ‘Non-Institutional’
caught my attention. The confusion about their being accessible and
approachable was getting clearer. That this was not the sign of a weak state
but was the intended purpose on which the whole government is structured. The
conscious effort to descend from the pedestal of the ruler to the ground to
serve the citizens. I perhaps had found my answer and the food for thought for
our situation back in our own country which we rule ourselves.
From awe-inspiring buildings which are named various Seva
Bhawan, people with cadres which end with some Seva (Service), people from
amidst us operate in a black box inaccessible to many. Forget accountability
even they have insulated themselves from being questioned by the public. The
people who do these are not from outside but are people like us. But then why
do they behave differently or like a ruler when their role changes? Do they elevate
themselves to a different class because of the power and privilege they enjoy
and behave as the role expects them to? Is it because of the general acceptance
of the society of that role? To a large extent – Yes.
So much has been the acceptance and internalization of
this that a common man doesn’t react to being violently pushed aside to give
way to the passing VIP cavalcade. Being abused if he stops his car near Gate
No. 1 of the Secretariat; being rudely dealt with by a peon in an office when
he realizes that the visitor doesn’t pose a threat to his job. A junior officer
when is ill-treated by his superior considers this as an occupational hazard.
It is not limited to the common man only. An officer immediately on his
retirement when gets harassed by his former colleagues or juniors who reported
to him once is not seen as an exception. He is just being meted out what he had
done to others. The smart ones choose to bribe and butter their way through the
system.
Are they in line with what they are supposed to be? While
addressing the first batch of IAS officers and retired ICS officers told them
that from the ones who ruled to serve you will change to serve to rule. 74
years after gaining independence from being ruled by the Brits and their loyal
officers, the common man still is governed by a set of mindsets who feel that
they are here to rule the populace in the guise of serving them. This CLASS is
the new CASTE.
There exist two worlds one for the rulers and the other
for the ruled. Two worlds – the world of the former colonizers and the world of
their colonies. In these 74 years, our former rulers and the global colonizers
have started the sincere process of governance with the attitude of service at
its core, but we seem to be stuck to that binary legacy of the ruler and the
ruled.
At the core of this rut is our mindset. The mindset of an average citizen and that of the ones whose job is to serve the citizens. The mindset of an average citizen is to break away from the situation where he is not fairly treated but to Segway into a class where he can use his power and position - no one tries to change things. The cycle continues. In how many years will be the next discussion be held where the administrators will sit with the designers to consciously redesign the next Commissionerate building which is open and inviting and not imposing and awe-inspiring? When will a common man rise from the pits to change the status quo?
Till that happens we have to fill our chests with pride watching how great our rulers are and staying in a state of awe seeing their impressive buildings.
Thursday, 18 November 2021
From Vijay to Deepak Sehgal; the changing role of Indian Male
THE AIRPORT WAS UNEXPECTEDLY CROWDED FOR A WEEKEND EARLY morning; the chill and constant drizzle since the last 4/5 days had done little to reduce the rush. Waiting for my turn at the security check, I was looking at the people and their movements ahead of me. Some were breezing past, and some were goofing up causing the snarl.
People traveling to the Goas and Gorakhpurs were all in one queue.
Ahead of me
was this girl in her early 30s who stood out because of the way she was dressed
in that damp chilly winter Bengaluru morning. Her slinky dress hung well past
her knees, but the designer had chosen to lop off the back by three quarters to
make some fashion statement.
The hushed
exchange of words coming from a family standing behind though was not very
audible, but one could guess that it’s the girl and the dress was the cause of
mirth. I had joined the discussion mentally without realizing it.
My idle mind
was processing questions relating to her age, her educational background, her
social status, what made her wear that dress when people all around were
desperate to cover themselves up. I was trying to slot it to a rational
framework to fit her not so justifiable sartorial choice.
So many questions and thoughts. It broke when I realized that I was standing right at the belt to drop my hand baggage for screening. A few minutes later I could feel that I had overcome with the emotion of guilt as if I had violated that poor girl and her boundaries. Why was I feeling guilty? Are we as human beings naturally not expected to analyze things constantly as they happen around us?
After settling near the departure gate, I started
reflecting.
In this scene in Dostana, Seetal Sahni, a role played by Zeenat Aman hauls up a roadside Romeo to the police station for whistling at her and singing a suggestive song. Vijay, the Inspector in charge played by Amitabh Bacchan locks the delinquent and like any good man of those times, counseled the affected party to change her ways for her safety and public decency. His long dialogue penned by Salim-Javed included sentences like ‘Log ish kapde mein dekhke seeti nahin to kya mandir mein ghanti bajayange? Zeenat was seen mostly covered up in the rest of the movie which means the girl was disciplined.
That was 1980.
Dostana:
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=530OND2MQig).
Cut to 2016; in the movie Pink; the same Amitabh this time playing a lawyer seals his closing statement with his epoch-making thunderous ‘A NO means NO’ dialogue sending a message to the patriarchy, misogyny, and all the moral police in the society that whatever may be the background of the girl, her dress, the situation and the act she was found doing when she says NO her wishes SHALL have to be respected.
Pink:
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZRJE7oufEzU)
While the audience of Dostana agreed with what Amitabh said THEN and the audience of Pink also agreed with what Amitabh said NOW. In these two scenes society felt that this is what men should do. Then it was expected good men to advise, now they are advised not to advise. If a remake of Dostana is planned now will Salim-Javed write a similar dialogue and Amitabh agree to deliver it? No! These two dialogues of Amitabh as Inspector Vijay to Lawyer Deepak Saigal perhaps best describe the evolution of the role of the male in our society in these three decades.
In 2008 when
a lady journalist Soumya Viswanathan was mysteriously found dead in Delhi while
returning from her late-night beat. Hell broke loose when the then CM, Sheela
Dixit suggested that the lady journalists avoid venturing out in the night. The
reaction to her statement was noisier than what the death of the journalist had
created. She was called out for her insensitive patriarchal condescending
statement despite being a woman. She was asked to SHUT UP and instead do her
job of making the streets of Delhi safer. Perhaps our parents in this situation
would still say what she said, she chose not to react. Biju Pattnaik in her position
perhaps would have said like what Amitabh said in Dostana in the 80s in his
inimitable ways but imagine the size of the backlash he would have faced.
I after
thinking deeply about these changes realized how brick by brick the role of men
in our society has been changed. His role as a physically superior, Protector,
Provider, Guardian, Custodian of the family, and responsible towards the society
has not only been questioned but challenged. So much so that they are now
conditioned into feeling guilty if they engage in any one of the above acts.
They have
been asked and taught not to judge, not to give an opinion, and to shut up,
keep off, stay off, look the other way, walk away from most of their so-called
masculine roles. The poor man as a father can’t give his opinion on his children
fearing patriarchy, on his wife fearing the label of being chauvinistic, on other women,
misogyny, to his friends fearing the label sexist.
Society
evolves at a glacial pace with one generation drawing inspiration from its
preceding generation and mostly leaving theirs as a leitmotif for the next. On International
Men’s Day, my thought goes out to the men of my generation, whose role has been
changed so much and so fast that if whatever he does will ever qualify as a positive
example in the future? Men look like the new dartboard.
Friday, 12 November 2021
Benne Masala Dosa and COP26
As I sat in this neighborhood restaurant in Bangalore enjoying my sinful Benne Dosa dripping of hot butter I saw the picture of a smiling face on the counter, garlanded; It seemed familiar. It was the picture of Puneet Rajkumar the heartthrob of millions. He had tragically died of a heart attack while working out in the gym; he was only 46. Today happens to be the last day of COP26 Glasgow, where the world leaders had huddled to declare the world of their commitments to take actions to save the world from overheating – which is projected to rise by 2.7 C by the end of this century.
My mind sensed that there was something common that connected these two events. It started brewing in my mind triggered by a cup of freshly brewed
filter coffee. I let my mind wander.
I am no doctor but the new age
obsession to build a six-pack herculean body fed on a custom-made diet and
exercise regime is what our body evolutionarily perhaps was not designed to
take. Some of us have redefined what once was called fitness and have
replaced it with the picture of a roman wrestler whose sole purpose of existence was only to eat
and fight. Nothing morally wrong in what Puneet was doing one would say but did
he overdo his fitness bit? His fans and friends must be wishing what if he had not
overdone this.
The climate change situation is alarming,
and it’s said that there is no time, and we need to act fast. The world leaders
chose to stay non-committal and have let the slide continue. We have clearly
overdone many things in our pursuit of comfort and convenience over the past two
hundred years. And I am sure that soon we will regret that we didn’t act in time in the
past.
A friend from the past had called
up yesterday and we spoke long over the phone catching up on things after years. This
once used to be a daily routine between us till things turned sour. I was awkward
and not comfortable speaking to someone after a long gap. After years of detachment
when I look back, I realize how I had overstepped my limits and overstayed in
that space. This is a pang of guilt, the burden of which I carry even now.
Many of us live with a
sense of loss after losing someone dear, emotionally scarred, harboring the
feeling of hurt because of broken relationships. The earth with its air,
water soil damaged irreversibly because of our own lifestyle and realized in hindsight that all these things which have damaged us today could have been
avoided had we paused or stopped at the right time.
Not that we didn’t know, there
were dozens of omens, alerts, and advice of the impending danger but we had
chosen to ignore for pleasure or short-term gains. Why do we choose to do so? Why
do we miss that right moment when we should have slowed, paused, stopped,
or stepped back and prevented things from worsening further? What happens to the rational man at these critical junctures?
Ignore all these discussions; should I, myself not have opted for a regular dosa instead of this buttery treat?
Friday, 29 October 2021
A Talk During Climate Change
Sharing an interesting conversation between a wise senior and his adolescent partner which I overheard during my morning walk today. What was heartening was the curiosity of the boy and the way his senior led him during the discussion to help him understand the relationship between human action and climate change.
Today is the anniversary of the 1999 super cyclone and the #COP26glasgow is about to start in a few days. Discussion of this kind assures us that there is still hope left. But the passivity of the administrative wing of the government is so distant from this global issue while its own policy declaration sheds crocodile tears actually is the real cause of alarm.
Q. What is this Super Cyclone
I see being discussed in the media?
A cyclone had happened on this
day of 29th October 1999 over Paradeep. People saw wind speed up to 260
Kmph and some 10,000 people died. It continues to be the worst we have faced so
far but we are not sure what’s coming next and when. From that day we have seen
so many cyclones big and small and the last one was Amphan which luckily
bypassed Odisha. It is happening due to climate change.
Q. What is Climate Change and
what is this discussion that I see in the media?
Climate Change is the dramatic change
in the weather pattern caused by the rise in Green House Gases in the environment
which can be attributed to industrial and individual human activities.
Q. What’s the problem? We seem
to be better prepared now to face it.
Yes, on the surface, from 10000 deaths
to 218 now we seem to be better prepared, but the total cost of damage is huge,
and it reverses so much of developmental outcomes.
Humanity is facing the twin challenges
of the desperate need for development and the catastrophic outcome of damages done
to the environment because of its activities over the last hundred plus years. Humanity
now stands facing an irreversible global crisis that is much bigger than the
extinctions of the past. It stands to affect everyone in ways we are not
prepared to tackle. The benefits of all the development in one area can get
swept away just by one cyclone. Most parts of Mumbai can get submerged if the
sea level rises by a meter. This will have a chain effect that will impact those
who are thousands of miles away. The economy is like our environment - there
are no boundaries. Humanity is collectively facing it together.
Q. What are the choices we
have?
We don’t have the choice of opting
for one and not the other. Both are not mutually exclusive but are highly
interdependent. One has to balance it and slow the pace of damage to bring the earth
to an equilibrium.
Q. Then how do we balance it?
It’s left with just one choice to
conduct its activities responsibly. That is first by ensuring that the global
value chain does its best by closing the leakages at all levels of economic activities
to minimize resource depletion, minimization of waste and emission.
This is easier said than done!
Yes, that is the reason why this discussion
is being made. Human activities involve just not his lifestyle, attitude, and behaviour
in its simplistic manifestation but the same and additionally the interest of
the thousands of organizations big and small who take part in production till waste
management.
Q. How do we tackle this?
First by being responsible. By
being responsible we mean that the fact of depletion, waste, and emission arising
directly from his activities should remain in very entities subconscious and he
should feel responsible to minimize it by changing his behaviour and constantly
looking at newer ways to constantly reduce it.
Q. Is it possible?
Theoretically being carbon
neutral is impossible but the intent to go neutral and change in the behaviour
at every individual or value chain level can show dramatic change at the level
of Society, Environment and Individual.
Q. How?
When we talk of change in behaviour
or practice at the level of organizations, we talk of our usage; how properly
we use it and keep it maintained. We all know how a properly used and
maintained car not only gives good mileage but remains in working condition well
beyond its official life. The change in the behaviour can immediately be seen
at the level of the environment in reduced emissions, extended life means that
the load on the resources at the level of production and manufacturing is
lessened and the efficiency and extended life of the car reduces the total cost
of ownership of the individual.
Well, it's simple right?
Though to a motivated person, it is.
But very difficult at the level of organizations which have thousands of
people, acres of real estate, and thousands of micro and small assets of
hundreds of categories. And then there are well-established interests deeply
entrenched in keeping the system inefficient and being inefficient in an
unsupervised setup.
Q. What is the way?
Technology has come to the rescue
of individuals and enterprises to help them do responsible business. It helps
organizations establish a system of proper use and maintenance of their assets
by its human resources. Smart monitoring tools can not only govern all the
organization's activities but also provide a measurement of the benefits which
is accrued at the level of organization, environment, and society.
Q. Then what’s stopping us?
Well, that’s something you need
to answer. What is stopping you from being responsible?
Friday, 2 July 2021
Riding on a broom to the Moon
Many would have heard this story of JFK visiting NASA space center. He spots a janitor with a broom, introduces himself, and asks him what he is doing.
"Well, Mr. President," the janitor responded, "I'm helping put a man on the moon."
To many, this janitor was a menial worker just cleaning the building and his contribution to the stopped there. But the larger story unfolding around him in the background, he was the proud member of a team that was helping to make history. Is it not?
Here is the point. It's not the janitor but the leader behind
this mission who had injected that sense of belongingness into the team which aligned
everyone with a higher purpose which the organization is pursuing.
Was he an aberration or we can find such motivated members across organizations? How many people do you feel we would bump into in an organization who have that sense of pride because of the purpose of the organization and also for the direct and indirect contribution of their role to the organization achieving its objectives?
A trip in public transport, a field trip or
a visit to an organization offers beautiful opportunities to us to observe
people and their relationship with the organizations they work for. More
technically speaking if they are aligned with the purpose of the organization
they are working for.
A question about their work mostly does not elicit anything beyond the
department and their job description at the most. The relationship between his
role and its contribution to the organization in achieving its goals will
always be missing. No matter how large or small your role, you are contributing
to the larger story unfolding within your life, your business, and your
organization. Why is this lost on most of the members?
What do organization leaders do about it?
Dr. John Paul Kotter, Professor of Leadership, Emeritus, at
Harvard Business School, author, and founder of the management consulting
firm Kotter International created this organizational change business
strategy.
[Read more at:
https://www.experiencetolead.com/three-methods-of-organizational-alignment/]
It’s one thing to hope for such alignment in an organization but
very difficult to achieve in its totality. Many variables at each of its constituents
and the ecosystem it is being tried in make it a challenging task. But when
your entire team embraces that type of attitude and belief system, incredible
things can happen.
So let us give it a try!
The Culture of Quality
A few days back few of my friends got into a casual conversation over someone’s posting on his Facebook wall on this slogan ‘Make in India’.
I commented that our country will continue to remain hopeless if there
is general feeling and accepted belief that to excel in one's chosen field, he
has to leave his own country. Because we have not produced anything
worthwhile after giving ‘0’ to humanity, hence we do not get the world’s investment
attention. To which a friend quipped, quality is available to people who Value quality,
and we don’t value quality.
Don’t we value quality? Don’t we expect quality? Yes, we do.
Most of our cribbing hovers around the falling standards in every sphere
around us. From relationships, the education system, organizations, and society
at large. Start any discussion on quality everyone jumps into this trip – how
they only see mediocrity and averages around them. This blame narrative is
mostly heard in the academic communities which now are infamous for their
dangerously falling standards.
When everyone expects high quality, then why don’t we get it?
If our chat on Fb both of us were talking about the same thing - about the culture of the society which values quality, but I additionally was hinting at our behavior which contributes to the collective societal value system. Around that time, I chanced upon a video snippet by the author Simon Sinek where he was breaking down the society with its Culture as Value + Behaviour.
Though the value can be at the collective and individual level, the behavior is always individual. I had this personal experience recently which is relevant to this issue of individual behavior and how it evolves in its ecosystem.
I had written a small note on my project as a primer. Though I felt that
this is good enough for the immediate needs, something deep inside told me that
this needs improvement. And only experts from this field can help. I sent it across
to two academician friends who work in the related space; expecting them to
find that elusive scope for improvement.
One sent back after few hours with few corrections which were nothing
more than typos - was expectedly disappointed. The other sent it back a day
later with detailed comments and suggestions. Enthused by the feedback, I
joined the editing effort and made changes as suggested and sent back hoping
that it’s the end of it.
No! she sent back with more comments. That went on more than 4 times.
If one compares the product with the first version; he can see two
different documents – both classes apart. The end-product bore the signature of
that habit of someone to naturally push things for excellence and not to stop
before achieving it.
Was the former insincere? My answer will be no!
Both are the product of two different cultures. One culture values
quality and the other does not. Because the former does not let average pass
the gate; she has grown in the culture of striving to achieve excellence in her
work and that has formed into a habit that now manifests in her behavior.
Thousands like her are produced in that culture and contribute back to the
culture through their behavior. Quality is a by-product of what our Society
collectively values and nurtures and the discipline to which we individually
agree to submit ourselves to.
Let us face the truth and bite the bitter pill. To expect a culture of
quality or excellence in our own lives, in our organizations we need to start
practicing it ourselves. It can only happen by first not accepting the average quality
just because there are people around us who accept it. Let us submit ourselves
to the grind of polishing our work through umpteen iterations till it reaches a
higher level of excellence. When we expect it from our employees, our clients would
be expecting it from us.
Sunday, 10 January 2021
The Same Dawn
Predawn sky.
From Love to Love
Love, I understand your feelings and the depth of your love for me and I'm in acute pain now while writing this letter to you. We both ...
-
Just a day before 29 th April 2020, if anyone had asked me who my top 10 favorite male actors are, he would not have found a mention - m...
-
By the beginning of June after enduring the harshness of the hot and humid Indian summer season from March, the nation starts looking skywar...
-
Two incidents and a vitriolic exchange of words between two interest groups kept the media space filled towards the second fortnight of Apri...